In the past 15 years, striking progress has been made in our understanding of the mechanisms underlying chronic inflammatory airway disease as well as the predisposing and interfering factors. These insights have resulted in a more holistic and personalised approach to the diagnosis and management of chronic inflammatory airway diseases including their comorbidities. At the annual congress of the European Respiratory Society (ERS), held in Madrid from 28 September–2 October, several novel data on different topics within the respiratory field have been presented in a variety of lectures, hot topic sessions, and special symposia. This review will focus on the latest developments in the field of asthma and its management including some highlights of ERS 2019.
In- and outdoor air pollution: respiratory health concern
The effects of air pollution and subsequent climate change on human health are increasingly worrisome. Undoubtedly, the expanding urbanisation, industrialisation, (air) traffic, and other human outdoor activities account for the massive emission of particulate matter (PM) and several pollutants, such as carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide, as major causes of the greenhouse effect, global warming, and climate change [1]. Specifically, air pollution and global working may both directly and indirectly affect the respiratory system, while the allergenicity of some plants is being promoted; for example, due to changed allergen composition or longer pollen seasons [2].
Apart from the harmful outdoor substances, indoor pollutants should not be overlooked. The latter include household cleaning products [3], tobacco smoke (including e-cigarettes vaping), gas cooking, open fireplaces, wood-burning stoves, and waste-incinerators. Apart from inflicting serious respiratory diseases including COPD, lung cancer, and upper respiratory tract diseases, constituents of tobacco smoke can also induce or worsen asthma at young age [4,5]. Based on their negative health effects addressed by an ERS task force [6], the ERS recently denounced e-cigarettes in an official statement.
Furthermore, the ERS 2019 dedicated a large session—including 77 posters—to air pollution. Several research groups across the world reported on various aspects and components of air pollution on respiratory health in both paediatric [7,8] and adult populations [9]. Specifically, there were several reports on detrimental effects of PM and wood stoves on the airways [10,11]. Using different statistical approaches, Dr Alicia Guillien (Université Grenoble Alpes, France) and colleagues studied the association of several aspects of the exposome (i.e. totality of human environmental and lifestyle exposures) on lung function parameters in adults with asthma (who participated in the EGEA2 study 2003–2006) [9]. They found that some urban and air pollutant factors are associated with lower lung function. Interestingly, a Portuguese study investigated the effects of an inflammatory diet (assessed by the dietary inflammatory index [DII]) on asthma characteristics and outcomes in association with indoor pollution in children [12]. They found that an inflammatory diet increases the risk of asthma for both PM2.5 (OR 1.67; 95% CI 1.03–2.73) and PM10 (OR 1.75; 95% CI 1.07–2.87) levels, highlighting the role of the diet’s inflammatory characteristics in modulating the effects of indoor pollution on asthma risk.
In addition to a plethora of reports on detrimental health effects associated with air pollution, there were also presentations on initiatives and programmes to educate stakeholders and raise awareness to improve the environment and promote fresh air [13].
The bottom line is that nationwide programmes are needed to attract and keep the attention of all stakeholders on this burning matter in the joint effort to try and revert the devastating effects of air pollution and climate change on the environment and human health.
Microbiome: macro-impact
The importance of a well-balanced microbiome to warrant a good health status is increasingly recognised. Recently, Dr Pirkka Kirjavainen (National Institute for Health and Welfare, Finland) and colleagues published on the impact of both the external and internal microbiome and their major role in the modulation of asthma, allergy, and associated conditions: i.e. disease-promoting or disease-protecting [14]. At the ERS 2019, Prof. Markus Ege (Ludwig-Maximilians-University of Munich, Germany) reported on the environmental microbiome and its links to allergies, and Dr Hermelijn Smits (Leiden University, the Netherlands) commented on the links between exposure to helminth parasites and asthma development [15]. Interesting new data came from a study investigating severe asthma phenotypes using induced sputum microbiome profiles of a subset of patients from the U-BIOPRED adult cohort, and cluster-wise stability was assessed after 12–18 months of a prospective follow-up [16]. Based on the microbiome from induced sputum, the researchers were able to identify 2 distinct severe asthma phenotypes. In addition, they found a relative stability of the microbiome-driven phenotypic clusters over time underscoring its potential for precision medicine approaches.
Fundamental changes in GINA2019
Risk reduction and prevention
The recently updated GINA guidelines include some fundamental changes focusing on risk reduction and prevention (i.e. reducing exacerbations associated with accelerated lung function decline and prevention of adverse events associated with overuse of corticosteroids), as well as further implementation of precision medicine guided by biomarkers [17].
Based on emerging evidence that severe exacerbations can also occur in patients with milder disease, GINA2019 now recommends symptom-triggered controller therapy to be combined with rescue medication in treatment steps 1 and 2. This recommendation is based on data coming from large clinical studies (e.g. SYGMA, START) showing superior disease control with inhaled corticosteroids (ICS) added to as-needed relievers (short-acting beta-agonists [SABA]) or combinations with ICS/LABA as needed compared with SABA only in patients with mild asthma [18,19]. This may implicate that, for example, in cases of seasonal house dust mite (HDM)-driven (intermittent or mild persistent) asthma, patients should no longer be prescribed as-needed relievers only [17]. Potentially, this “prevention-focused approach” might shift the place of allergen immunotherapy (presently on step 4 for eligible patients) to earlier treatment steps; however, this is still a point of debate.
Based on increased awareness of the (serious) side effects of corticosteroids, GINA2019 advocates lower doses of ICS as preferred regimen across all treatment steps, while implementing add-on controllers or biologics at the distinct treatment steps in selected patient populations.
At the ERS2019, some post-hoc analyses of the SYGMA studies were presented, underscoring the benefits of as-needed budesonide/formoterol treatment versus terbutaline prn only on several clinical outcomes in patients with mild asthma [20,21]. In addition, several studies of targeted therapies with biologicals (e.g. mepolizumab and dupilumab) showed corticosteroid-sparing effects in selected patients with severe asthma in addition to improving disease control and/or lung function [22-24].
Towards precision medicine
GINA2019 continues to recognise that asthma, in many cases, may appear to be “difficult-to-treat” because of a wrong diagnosis or the presence of modifiable factors (or: treatable traits) including poor adherence, incorrect inhaler technique, smoking, or comorbidities, which should be pro-actively assessed [17].
In line with the advocacy for the implementation of precision medicine into clinical practice [25]—which more recently has been further extended with treatable mechanisms [26]—these principles are now increasingly being incorporated into the concurrent guidelines [17].
Indeed, GINA2019 underscores the presence of several clinical phenotypes (i.e. asthma with late-onset, allergic, and non-allergic asthma, asthma with obesity, and asthma with persistent airway flow limitation) that might require a different approach. Despite not recognising a strong relationship between specific pathological features and particular clinical patterns or treatment responses, GINA2019 proposes treatment algorithms (based on composite biomarkers) to assess and manage difficult-to-treat and purely refractory (i.e. severe) asthma and to predict the response to type2-targeted treatment options for uncontrolled severe asthma (step 5) with or without comorbidities such as allergy, atopic dermatitis, and/or nasal polyps [17]. At the ERS2019, a session was dedicated to the management of severe asthma with highlights from the recently published ERS/ATS guideline including (GRADE) evidence-based treatment algorithms –some of which slightly differ from those presented in GINA2019 due to different methodologies and a different expert panel [17,27].
mHealth supports adherence and self-monitoring
Despite several innovative treatment options, patient education and treatment adherence continue to call for attention. At the ERS2019, several insightful reports on treatment adherence have been presented showing an overall low adherence to inhaled controlled–according to some studies as low as 43% [28]. In contrast, combining data from 10 key studies on the topic, Culling and Dennison found conflicting associations between adherence to inhaled therapy and clinical outcomes in adult patients with severe asthma [29]. Over a follow-up period of 12 years, Dr Iida Vähätalo (Seinäjoki Central Hospital, Finland) and colleagues concluded that better adherence to ICS was associated with clinical features of more severe disease but not with symptoms or inflammatory markers [30]. Clearly, these outcomes need further investigation.
Alternatively, the rapidly evolving mobile health (mHealth) technology may help to improve adherence through patients’ empowerment based on self-monitoring, personalised feedback, and education. Currently, there are several mobile applications (apps) available through digital distribution platforms but only few qualify for applicability in daily clinical care [31,32].
In line with this trend, Uddhav Vaghela (Imperial College London, United Kingdom) and colleagues investigated the feasibility and viability of personalised asthma action plans (PAAPs) by primary and secondary healthcare professionals and patients (18–65 years). Besides anticipated drawbacks such as data overload, quality issues, and overdependence on technology, it was concluded that digital PAAPs, if a validated algorithm is used in close collaboration with key stakeholders, could help improve self-management for patients [33].
Another closely associated topic is the emerging development of smart inhalers connected to a smartphone aimed to improve inhalation technique and/or adherence. These e-modules (i.e. sensors, chips) are either attached externally (as add-on tools) or integrated in the inhaler and can monitor its use in real-life setting. They offer potential health and economic benefits (i.e. reducing health care consumption by decreasing severe exacerbations and prescriptions of expensive medications), but their added value needs to be confirmed in health-economic analyses [34].
One airway concept revived: asthma and upper airways comorbidities
In parallel with the development of biologicals targeting the underlying mechanisms, there has been a revival in appreciating the type2-conditions associated with and/or affecting concomitant asthma, including atopic dermatitis, allergic rhinitis (AR), and chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) with and without nasal polyps (CRSwNP; CRSsNP) [17,35-37]. Indeed, several biologicals targeting type2-pathways (IL-5 and IL-4/13) showed clinical benefits in patients with CRSwNP with or without concomitant asthma [38-40], underscoring the urge to treat all parts of the respiratory system to optimise control in patients with type2-chronic inflammatory airway disease [17,37,41].
The multi-facetted association between the different airway compartments has been highlighted in a unique ENT session during the ERS 2019. Prof. Peter Hellings (UZ Leuven, Belgium) stressed the importance to differentiate between anatomical and mucosal abnormalities in nasal obstruction [42]. The latter being often associated with chronic inflammation requiring further investigation beyond the upper airway compartment [36]. Thought-generating data came from a study by Dr Plamena Novakova (Medical University of Sofia, Bulgaria) and colleagues showing no association between blood eosinophil count and disease control (measured by CAT score) in their cohort of AR patients [43]. A recent comprehensive review of remodelling of the upper airways highlights some striking differences in structural changes between patients with AR and patients with CRS [44]. While only modest structural changes were observed in AR, CRS phenotypes demonstrated epithelial hyperplasia, increased matrix deposition, and degradation along with accumulation of plasma proteins, consistent with more extensive remodelling. Future studies need to establish if long-term treatment with targeted treatments can, at least partly, revert the structural changes within the upper (and lower) airways.
Targeted treatment options: something old – something new…
In a recent review, Dr Jonathan Corren (UCLA Medical Center, USA) discusses several currently available treatment options for uncontrolled (severe) asthma. In summary, for type2 uncontrolled (severe) asthma, which is currently the best defined pheno/endotype in terms of underlying mechanisms, biomarkers, and targets, 3 types of targeted biologicals are currently available: i.e. anti-IgE (if allergy-driven), anti-IL-5 (if eosinophilic), and anti-IL-4/13 (a broader type2 indication) (Figure 1) [45].
Figure 1: Pathways underlying type2- asthma [45]
A, allergic asthma; B, nonallergic T2 asthma.
B, B cell; BM, basement membrane; CRTH2, chemoattractant receptor-homologous molecule expressed on TH2 cells (or prostaglandin D2[DP2] receptor); DC, dendritic cell; DR3, death receptor 3; E, eosinophil; EC, epithelial cell; GATA3, GATA3 transcription factor; KIT, stem cell receptor; GC, goblet cell; IL, interleukin; ILC2, innate lymphoid cell2; MC, mast cell; OX40L, OX40 ligand; PGD2, prostaglandin D2; SM, smooth muscle cell; ST2, IL-33 receptor; T, naïve T helper cell; TSLP, thymic stromal lymphopoietin.
Reprinted from Corren J. J Allergy Clin Immunol Pract. 2019;7:1394-403. Copyright © 2019, with permission from Elsevier.
In a topical symposium, Dr Mario Castro (University of Kansas Medical Center, USA) presented the most recent data derived from the large, phase 3 Liberty Asthma QUEST and VENTURE studies of dupilumab, a fully human monoclonal antibody (MoAb) directed at the IL-4 receptor alpha (IL-4Rα) blocking the IL-4/IL-13 axis. In these placebo-controlled studies, dupilumab showed substantial improvements in asthma control and lung function in combination with a reduction in type2-biomarkers and OCS-sparing effects in patients with moderate-to-severe and severe asthma [23,24,46]. Interestingly, despite its indication for type2 uncontrolled severe asthma characterised by increased blood eosinophils and/or FeNO levels, several of the reported beneficial effects were achieved irrespective of the level of type2 biomarkers before commencing treatment [47]. The most commonly reported adverse event consisted of injection-site reaction.
A novel approach to blocking this dual inflammatory pathway by an inhaled anti-IL-4Rα MoAb was presented by Prof. Mark FitzGerald (University of British Columbia, Canada) showing efficacy by reducing FeNO in patients with mild asthma across all tested doses; subsequent clinical studies are being awaited [48].
Further upstream approaches, e.g. with anti-alarmins, are anticipated to have still a broader clinical effectiveness (blocking both the type2 and non-type2 pathways). Presently, phase 3 studies with tezepelumab (anti-thymic stromal lymphopoietin) in severe uncontrolled asthma are ongoing [45].
Apart from biologicals, other promising pharmacotherapeutic approaches targeting type2 pathways include prostaglandin D2 receptor (DP2, also referred to as chemo-attractant receptor, homologous molecule expressed by Th2 cells [CRTH2]) antagonists [45,49]. At the ERS2019, several mechanistic studies on these novel drugs were presented, while phase 3 results are expected in 2020.
Apart from type2 asthma, approximately 50% of adult patients present with non-type2 or type2-low asthma, associated with (viral) infections, occupational irritants, and oxidative stress, which is usually unresponsive to ICS [50]. Non-type2 asthma represents a heterogeneous group including paucigranulocytic and neutrophilic inflammatory phenotypes with less defined underlying mechanisms, biomarkers, and (targeted) therapeutic options [51].
In a recent publication based on animal observations, Dr Omar Tliba and colleagues describe potential mechanisms underlying paucigranulocytic asthma (PGA) where environmental triggers interact with structural cells (including neurons and airway smooth muscle cells) to produce the pathobiology of asthma characterised by fixed bronchoconstriction and increased airway hyperresponsiveness (Figure 2). As PGA usually does not respond well to ICS, alternative therapies including combined bronchodilators (beta2-agonists and M2 antagonists), mast cell-stabilisers, or bronchial thermoplasty (BT) could be of clinical benefit [52]. At the ERS2019, data from the BT global registry have been presented showing sustained clinical effectiveness of BT in patients with severe asthma uncontrolled by standard therapy in real-life settings [53].
Figure 2: Model of the Mechanisms Underlying Paucigranulocytic Asthma [52]
ACh, acetylcholine; ECM, extracellular matrix; IL, interleukin; MCP-1, monocyte chemoattractant protein-1; M2R, muscarinic receptor 2; M3R, muscarinic receptor 3; TGF-β, transforming growth factor beta.
Reprinted from Tliba O, et al. JACI 2019;143:1287-94. Copyright © 2019, Elsevier.
Future directions
So far, significant progress has been made in our understanding of the heterogeneous nature and underlying mechanisms of asthma, which has allowed for the development of targeted treatments and subsequent implementation of precision medicine in clinical practice. However, several questions remain unanswered.
Today, asthma is still a chronic, incurable disease, affecting over 350 million individuals worldwide, which may still cause death as reported by the World Health Organization (WHO).
The long-term safety, clinical effectiveness, and disease-modifying properties of the newly introduced targeted treatment options are being awaited, while mechanisms underlying type2-low asthma including applicable biomarkers and effective therapies are still an unmet need.
About the author: Apart from academic affiliations, Zuzana Diamant acts as Executive Medical and Scientific Director of Respiratory & Allergy at QPS-NL, a CRO that conducts early phase clinical studies for biotech and pharma companies. In the past 3 years, she received honoraria/consultancy fees from ALK, Aquilon, Acucort, AstraZeneca, Boehringer-Ingelheim, Gilead, HAL Allergy, MSD, and Sanofi-Genzyme
References
- Tong S. Lancet Planet Health 2019;Feb;3(2):e49-e50.
- D’Amato G, et al. Clin Exp Allergy 2008;38:1264-74.
- Wang M, et al. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2019;143(5):1892-1903.
- Vanker A, et al. Expert Rev Respir Med 2017;11(8):661-73.
- Belgrave DCM, et al. Lancet Respir Med 2018;6(7):526-34.
- Bals R, et al. Eur Respir J. 2019 Jan 31;53(2).
- Kuiper IN, et al. Eur Respir J. 2019; 54 (Suppl 63):A4872.
- Hansell A, et al. Eur Respir J. 2019; 54 (Suppl 63):A882.
- Guillien A, et al. Eur Respir J. 2019; 54 (Suppl 63):A721.
- Abramson MJ, et al. Eur Respir J. 2019; 54 (Suppl 63):A584.
- Pourazar J, et al. Eur Respir J. 2019; 54 (Suppl 63):A1641.
- Castro Mendes F, et al. Eur Respir J. 2019; 54 (Suppl 63):A2997.
- Van Gemert F, et al. Eur Respir J. 2019; 54 (Suppl 63):A1576.
- Kirjavainen PV, et al. Nat Med. 2019;25(8):1319.
- Obieglo K, et al. Parasite Immunol 2018;40(10):e12579.
- Ibrahim MIA, et al. Eur Respir J. 2019; 54 (Suppl 63):A5328.
- GINA 2019; https://ginasthma.org/gina-reports [Accessed on 1 Oct 2019].
- O’Byrne PM, et al. NEJM 2018;378:1865-76.
- Beasley R, et al. NEJM 2019;380:2020-30.
- Reddel H, et al. Eur Respir J. 2019; 54 (Suppl 63):A2309.
- FitzGerald M, et al. Eur Respir J. 2019; 54 (Suppl 63):A2367.
- Bel EH, et al. NEJM 2014;371(13):1189-97.
- Rabe KF, et al. NEJM 2018;378(26):2475-2485.
- Castro M, et al. NEJM 2018;378(26):2486-2496.
- Agusti A, et al. Eur Respir J. 2017;50(4). pii: 1701655.
- Chung KF, Adcock IM. Allergy 2019;74(9):1649-1659.
- Holguin F, et al. Eur Respir J. 2019; Sep 26. pii: 1900588
- Hassan M, et al. Eur Respir J. 2019;54 (Suppl 63):A641.
- Culling A, Dennison P. Eur Respir J. 2019;54 (Suppl 63):A67.
- Vähätalo I, et al. Eur Respir J. 2019;54 (Suppl 63):A2689.
- Sleurs K, et al. Allergy 2019;74(7):1292-1306.
- Galenus Health; https://apps.apple.com/nl/app/galenus-health/id1273173293
- Vaghela U, et al. Eur Respir J. 2019;54 (Suppl 63):A1571.
- Chrystyn H, et al. Respir Med 2019 Sep 12;158:24-32.
- Ariëns LF, et al. Allergy 2019 Oct 8. doi: 10.1111/all.14080.
- Brozek JL, et al. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2017;140(4):950-958.
- Fokkens WJ, et al. Allergy 2019 May 15. doi: 10.1111/all.13875.
- Gevaert P, et al. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2013;131(1):110-6.e1.
- Gevaert P, et al. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2011;128(5):989-95.e1-8.
- Bachert C, et al. Lancet 2019 Nov 2;394(10209):1638-1650
- Håkansson K, et al. PLoS One 2015;10(7):e0127228.
- Picavet VA, et al. Am J Rhinol Allergy 2012;26(6):493-6.
- Novakova P, et al. Eur Respir J. 2019;54 (Suppl 63): A1327.
- Samitas K, et al. Allergy 2018;73(5):993-1002.
- Corren J. J Allergy Clin Immunol Pract. 2019;7(5):1394-403.
- Corren J, et al. J Allergy Clin Immunol Pract. 2019 Sep 12. pii: S2213-2198(19)30775-5.
- Papi A, et al. Eur Respir J. 2019;54 (Suppl 63):A1685.
- Bruns I, et al. Eur Respir J. 2019;54 (Suppl 63):A5494.
- Diamant Z. Curr Opin Pulm Med. 2019;25(1):121-127.
- Israel E, Reddel HK. NEJM 2017;377:965-76.
- Diamant Z, et al. Allergy 2019;74(10):1835-1851
- Tliba O, et al. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2019;143:1287-94.
- Torrego Fernandez A, et al. Eur Respir J. 2019;54 (Suppl 63):A824.
Before the invention of the wheel… everything was a drag!
order generic tadalafil – buy cialis online cialis 20mg tablet
plaquenil 200mg ca – oral plaquenil 400mg buy hydroxychloroquine 400mg generic
ivermectin 10 mg – buy ivermectin 3 mg online stromectol 12 mg
buy cephalexin 500mg sale – buy cephalexin 125mg order erythromycin 500mg generic
sildenafil ca – order generic nolvadex purchase antabuse sale
rhinocort canada – quetiapine 100mg brand ceftin 500mg sale
buy bimatoprost pill – order methocarbamol generic trazodone uk
viagra online order – order viagra 100mg pills ranitidine 150mg drug
buy tadalafil without prescription – ivermectin 12 mg tablets ivermectin pills for humans
order generic tadalafil 40mg – cheapest ed pills male ed drugs
best casino online – online slot games order generic prednisone 10mg
prednisone without prescription – prednisone 40mg pills order isotretinoin 20mg
order amoxil 1000mg online cheap – brand amoxicillin 250mg purchase sildenafil online cheap
cialis 5mg pills – cialis 20mg cheap cialis tablet
price of stromectol – stromectol stromectol tablets buy azithromycin 500mg sale
order zithromax 500mg online cheap – medrol without a doctor prescription cost of methylprednisolone
metformin 1000mg tablet – order glucophage online cheap order generic lipitor 80mg
order norvasc 5mg generic – order omeprazole pill purchase omeprazole pills
metoprolol 50mg tablet – order atenolol 100mg generic buy cialis online safely
cialis ca – cialis 5mg sale sildenafil otc
world market world darknet market
stromectol 12mg – stromectol rx buy ivermectin canada
guide to darknet markets best australian darknet market [url=https://btcdarkwebmarket.com/ ]agora darknet market [/url]
tor markets 2022 grams darknet market search
cartel market url darknet drug links
vice city market darknet vice city darknet market
cartel darknet market dark0de market
tor market darknet aero market darknet
bitcoin dark web reddit darknet markets 2021
televend market link torrez link
darknet markets list torrez market
samsara darknet market cartel marketplace url
darknet market lists best darknet market australia
versus project market darknet tor dark web
tor2door market darknet cypher darknet market
wall street market darknet url darknet market guide reddit
nightmare market darknet cartel marketplace url
versus market alphabay market url
silkkitie darknet market cartel darknet market
cypher market darknet bohemia market link
incognito link silkkitie market
darknet market news wall street market darknet url
cartel market darknet vice city market
dream market darknet url torrez link
deep web drug links white house market
Spurdomarket market link darknet market ddos
monopoly link dark web drug markets
order clomid 50mg without prescription – albuterol brand cetirizine sale
world market link drug market
asap market biggest darknet market 2022
best darknet market 2022 alphabay market url
best darknet market reddit wallstreet market darknet
empire darknet market hansa darknet market
archetyp market url tor markets 2021
vice city market link Spurdomarket market darknet
biggest darknet market 2022 darknet market guide
empire market darknet liberty darknet market
cannahome darknet market asap darknet market
darknet market comparison chart cartel marketplace
new darknet market reddit darknet market onion links
hansa darknet market black market prescription drugs for sale
how to get to darknet market best darknet market 2022
safe darknet markets agora darknet market
liberty link onion darknet market
world market drug market
daeva link best darknet markets
dark market url darknet credit card market
Spurdomarket market darknet dream market darknet
darknet market empire versus project market
cartel market darknet tor marketplace
dark web link darknet market avengers
2021 darknet market darknet market wiki
darknet seiten dream market darkmarket
dream market darknet link darknet market guide
darkc0de reddit darknet markets 2021
versus market darknet are there any darknet markets left
monopoly market darknet cypher link
hydra market darknet links markets
versus market url tor markets links
wall street market darknet darknet drug links
cannazon market darknet hydra market url
crypto market darknet the wall street market darknet
how to get to darknet market Silkkitie market darknet
tor market links televend link
darknet market avengers versus project link
cannahome market darknet markets 2021 reddit
uk darknet markets tor marketplace
vice city market darknet darkfox market
asap darknet market torrez market url
incognito link reddit darknet markets 2021
best darknet market for weed darknet dream market reddit
white house market darknet best darknet market reddit
white house market darknet darknet market url list
liberty link darkc0de market
darknet market stats darkc0de market
empire market darknet tor2door market darknet
darknet websites darknet market canada
darknet markets list hydra market
televend link world darknet market
darkfox link cartel market darknet
archetyp market url torrez market link
are there any darknet markets left hydra link
tor markets 2021 cartel market darknet
versus project market darknet reddit darknet markets 2022
versus project market darknet dark web markets
darknet drugs market darknet markets reddit 2022
darknet websites daeva market
dark0de link empire market darknet stats
zion market darknet darknet market list 2022
cannazon market darknet how to use darknet markets
tor2door market link white house darknet market
onion darknet market darkmarket 2021
guide to darknet markets darknet market url
deep web drug store wallstreet link
darknet market empire deep web drug url
darknet market links darknet market script
how to create a darknet market the wall street market darknet
top darknet markets 2022 tor market
asap market darknet bitcoin drugs market
darknet market lists silkkitie market
darknet markets reddit 2022 wallstreet market link
popular darknet markets vice city market link
darknet market search darkfox market
darknet market list silk road darknet market
cartel market link darknet market noobs
cannazon market darknet torrez market
olympus market darknet black market prices for drugs
versus project market link Silkkitie market link
wallstreet market spurdomarket market
darknet dream market how to use darknet markets
guide to darknet markets televend market link
best darknet markets legit darknet markets
world darknet market hydra darknet market
grey market darknet tor markets 2021
white house market link asap link
darkfox market darknet cannahome market darknet
hansa market darknet best darknet market 2021 reddit
cartel market url world market link
wall street market darknet url black market prices for drugs
best darknet market 2022 daeva market url
tor2door market link cypher market
russian darknet market what is the darknet market
incognito market darknet bohemia market url
core market darknet tor2door darknet market
wall street darknet market how to get to darknet market
darknet market news asap market
dark web sites aero market darknet
darknet dream market bitcoin dark web
grams darknet market price of black market drugs
world market url dark web link
torrez darknet market monopoly market link
alphabay market url darknet dream market
alphabay market darknet market url
bohemia darknet market darkweb markets
darknet market canada drug markets onion
darknet wallstreet market alphabay market
tor2door market asap market darknet
deep web drug store white house market url
empire market darknet darknet stock market
darkmarket url darknet wallstreet market
top darknet markets 2022 monopoly link
wall street market darknet link monopoly market darknet
most popular darknet market wallstreet market url
empire market darknet spurdomarket darknet market
black market prices for drugs darkmarket url
incognito darknet market olympus market darknet
spurdomarket market Silkkitie link
the wall street market darknet biggest darknet market 2021
current darknet markets darknet market avengers
darknet markets list bohemia market url
drug market cartel marketplace link
cannazon darknet market best darknet market 2022 reddit
vice city market hydra market link
dark0de link how to buy from the darknet markets
tor markets 2021 darkfox market url
tor dark web televend darknet market
torrez market dark market url
darknet markets list bohemia market darknet
hydra market darknet tor2door market link
darknet markets daeva market url
hydra link darknet market
darknet markets onion address darknet drug store
darknet market comparison cypher link
cartel market dark market 2021
versus market link televend darknet market
silk road darknet market darknet market bible
bitcoin dark web deep web drug store
archetyp market darknet monopoly darknet market
torrez link darknet drugs
reddit darknet market noobs darknet market stats
dark market onion darknet market news
reddit darknet markets 2021 monopoly market link
archetyp market white house market link
darknet market ddos agora darknet market
televend market best darknet market 2022
link darknet market vice city link
torrez darknet market 2021 darknet market
grey market darknet new darknet market reddit
archetyp market url darkmarket link
wall market darknet price of black market drugs
dark web markets darknet market list 2021
darknet market list 2021 darknet markets 2021
tor marketplace cartel market darknet
how to get to darknet market best darknet market 2022
versus market url safe darknet markets
darknet wall street market liberty market link
tor2door market darkfox darknet market
asap market liberty darknet market
guide to darknet markets reddit darknet market list 2021
white house market darknet hydra darknet market
darknet markets list world darknet market
darknet marketplace how to buy from the darknet markets
wallstreet market url current darknet markets
darknet market bible darknet drug store
bohemia market link dream market darknet link
Spurdomarket market link Silkkitie link
incognito link hansa market darknet
black market prescription drugs for sale tor2door link
incognito link darkc0de market
darknet market avengers alphabay market url
best darknet market 2021 alphabay link
darknet markets 2021 reddit darknet markets
darknet markets onion address cannahome market url
versus project darknet market safe darknet markets
darknet market news darknet market url
darkfox darknet market liberty darknet market
best darknet market for weed tor markets 2022
dark market url televend link
darkmarket 2022 archetyp market link
tor marketplace alphabay market
reddit darknet markets 2022 best darknet market australia
darkmarket darknet markets norge
darknet links markets bitcoin drugs market
darknet market prices tor market darknet
daeva market darknet how to use darknet markets
reddit darknet market list bohemia market link
darkfox market dark web drug markets
hydra darknet market cannahome market darknet
darknet drugs daeva market url
core market darknet nightmare darknet market
darknet market arrests versus market
darknet market guide reddit best australian darknet market
darknet drug links silkkitie darknet market
samsara market darknet liberty market darknet
dark0de market tor2door market darknet
best darknet market for lsd darkfox darknet market
how to access the darknet market wall street market darknet link
cypher market url versus project market link
dream market darknet url darknet credit card market
incognito market darknet incognito darknet market
archetyp darknet market darknet market url
tor darknet market reddit darknet market noobs
world market link darknet market sites
darknet markets 2022 reddit monopoly link
televend market url darknet market stats
torrez market cannazon market
silkkitie darknet market dark market
cypher market darknet top darknet markets 2022
cypher darknet market Silkkitie link
darknet market lists darknet market guide
tor2door market darknet Silkkitie link
black market prescription drugs for sale tor2door market
darknet market list 2021 bitcoin dark web
vice city link darknet market prices
darknet market black darknet market noobs
darknet market oz darknet empire market
bitcoin dark web black market illegal drugs
dark web markets darknet marketplace
new darknet market reddit new darknet markets
best darknet market for lsd dark0de darknet market
versus darknet market deep web markets
white house market darknet markets reddit
world market darknet vice city market link
zion market darknet archetyp market darknet
darknet markets wall street darknet market
wall street market darknet review nightmare darknet market
versus project market darknet new darknet market reddit
torrez market monopoly link
cartel market url versus darknet market
bitcoin dark web darknet dream market
Spurdomarket link zion market darknet
darkmarket tor2door market url
Spurdomarket link darknet market status
darknet market avengers deep sea darknet market
reddit darknet market noobs torrez market darknet
reddit darknet markets 2022 darkmarket
valhalla darknet market darknet market list 2022
darknet market list 2022 darkmarket
darknet markets list price of black market drugs
best darknet market 2021 dark market list
televend market darknet cannahome market
darknet market links dark web market
deep web drug links world darknet market
incognito market url world market darknet
white house darknet market popular darknet markets
black market drugs tor market
cypher market darknet market superlist
darknet markets 2021 reddit hydra market url
darkmarket url darkmarket link
bitcoin dark web cannahome market link
darknet market list reddit hydra market link
reddit darknet market list darknet links markets
dark web market list tor darknet markets
black market prescription drugs for sale cannahome market link
Silkkitie link darkfox market link
dark market link dark market url
cartel marketplace url world market darknet
versus project link darknet drugs market
darknet market oz monopoly market
darknet market onion links televend link
darkfox market darknet darknet market
darknet market ddos russian darknet market
how to buy from the darknet markets archetyp market url
tor market wall street darknet market
deep web markets wall street market darknet url
televend market darknet dark market 2022
cartel market url wall street market darknet review
Silkkitie link Spurdomarket market link
best darknet market australia darknet market prices
alphabay market hydra market darknet
darknet market ddos deep web drug links
cartel market darknet televend market
world market wallstreet market link
dark web markets white house link
best darknet market for weed darkfox market url
tor darknet markets darknet market comparison
world market versus project market url
bohemia market drug markets onion
darkmarket link bohemia market
incognito link darknet drug store
drug market vice city darknet market
olympus market darknet archetyp market url
deep web drug links darknet market list
darkmarket bitcoin dark web
darknet market onion links darknet market url
world market darknet silkkitie darknet market
darknet market oz best darknet market 2021 reddit
tor market url white house link
darknet market ddos vice city darknet market
tor market cannazon link
hansa darknet market darkmarket 2022
liberty market url tor markets links
darkmarket 2021 archetyp darknet market
cannahome darknet market darknet market oz
cannazon darknet market cannahome market url
silk road darknet market cypher darknet market
darknet market sites new darknet markets
aero market darknet darknet markets 2021
darknet market comparison versus project market url
hansa darknet market core market darknet
darknet market list reddit torrez darknet market
cartel darknet market Spurdomarket link
russian darknet market asap market url
cartel darknet market darknet dream market link
vice city market darknet darkmarket 2022
best darknet market 2022 darknet wallstreet market
wallstreet market darknet torrez market darknet
biggest darknet market 2021 darknet credit card market
darknet drugs deep web drug store
hydra market darknet agora darknet market
darknet drugs market silkkitie darknet market
bitcoin drugs market darknet drug market
how to buy from the darknet markets cartel marketplace url
dark web market links darknet market lists
darknet markets 2022 world market link
torrez market link darknet market reviews
how to get to darknet market deep web drug url
cartel marketplace link darkfox market link
darkc0de darknet seiten dream market
drug markets onion core market darknet
tor2door darknet market best darknet markets
darknet market url list wallstreet link
spurdomarket darknet market world darknet market
daeva market url tor2door market darknet
spurdomarket market versus darknet market
monopoly market darknet how to get on darknet market
darknet markets reddit best darknet market 2022 reddit
2021 darknet market archetyp market url
deep web drug markets dark market 2022
black market prices for drugs safe darknet markets
darknet market list 2022 empire market darknet
best darknet markets darkmarket
dark0de link wallstreet link
white house market darknet market canada
cannazon market best darknet market australia
darknet empire market monopoly market url
how to access the darknet market darknet market
empire market darknet black market drugs
archetyp link dark0de link
daeva darknet market versus project link
darknet market oz darknet markets 2022
darknet drugs market incognito market darknet
monero darknet markets televend market link
cypher market dark web markets
reliable darknet markets cypher market link
tor marketplace daeva link
darknet market links vice city market link
darkmarket list dark web market links
darknet market empire wallstreet market
cartel link grams darknet market search
torrez darknet market wall market darknet
darknet market empire tor2door darknet market
versus project market url reddit darknet market list 2022
tor2door market link torrez darknet market
tor darknet markets darkfox market link
2021 darknet market the wall street market darknet
black market prices for drugs tor2door market link
top darknet markets daeva market
best darknet market 2021 reddit darknet market search engine
versus market link best darknet market for weed
how to access the darknet market darknet market comparison
darknet market guide how to use darknet markets
cartel marketplace link tor dark web
alphabay darknet market asap market darknet
darknet market script current darknet markets
dark web markets televend link
guide to darknet markets olympus market darknet
versus project market link deep web drug url
darknet market comparison asap darknet market
cypher darknet market cartel darknet marketplace
best darknet market 2021 daeva darknet market
best darknet market australia reddit darknet market list
empire darknet market alphabay market url
dark market 2022 darknet markets 2021
deep web drug links zion darknet market
darknet websites darkfox darknet market
darkfox market url zion market darknet
world market link russian darknet market
wallstreet market url darknet markets 2021 reddit
nightmare market darknet hydra link
monopoly market darknet darkmarket 2022
best darknet market 2021 cypher market link
darknet drug market white house market url
asap link empire market darknet stats
best darknet market australia biggest darknet market 2022
tor darknet markets vice city market darknet
alphabay link darknet market noobs bible
tor market darknet darknet dream market reddit
silk road darknet market vice city market url
darknet dream market reddit darknet market comparison chart
cannazon market darknet market guide
versus link dark web drug markets
liberty market link alphabay link
darknet market search darknet market script
darknet seiten dream market darknet markets 2021 reddit
darknet markets reddit tor market darknet
darkmarket 2022 versus link
versus project darknet market darknet wall street market
dark market 2022 wall street market darknet url
tor2door market url bohemia market url
liberty market top darknet markets
silk road darknet market reddit darknet market list
bohemia market darknet torrez market link
darknet market comparison chart liberty market link
wall street market darknet link versus link
darknet links markets best darknet market 2022 reddit
biggest darknet market 2022 darkfox link
versus market wallstreet market link
darknet market url wall street market darknet reddit
how to buy from the darknet markets Spurdomarket link
tor market best darknet market reddit
grams darknet market search engine televend market
asap market darknet darknet market canada
darknet dream market torrez market link
cannahome market link reddit darknet markets 2022
zion market darknet current darknet markets
darknet market reddit asap market darknet
samsara darknet market darkc0de market
reddit darknet market list drug markets dark web
cannazon market darknet cannazon market
dark market url cartel market
legit darknet markets cartel market url
wallstreet market darknet seiten dream market
alphabay market link tor market links
grey market darknet vice city link
olympus darknet market tor2door market link
spurdomarket darknet market dark market url
darknet markets 2021 russian darknet market
cypher market url darknet gun market
how to access the darknet market vice city market url
darknet markets norge white house market darknet
darknet market prices dark web markets
daeva market link tor marketplace
dark0de market what is the darknet market
deep web drug links monopoly market darknet
price of black market drugs dark0de darknet market
spurdomarket darknet market tor2door link
darknet market ddos darknet market prices
daeva market darknet tor market darknet
tor2door market darknet cypher darknet market
are there any darknet markets left monopoly market url
reddit darknet market noobs televend darknet market
cartel market link darknet market black
samsara market darknet dark market 2021
versus market darknet market url list
darknet market list 2021 dark market url
darknet gun market 2021 darknet market
incognito market url torrez market darknet
price of black market drugs most popular darknet market
cartel market darknet dark web market list
darknet markets 2021 darknet markets norge
monopoly darknet market monopoly market url
wall street darknet market olympus darknet market
darkmarket 2021 wallstreet market url
incognito link white house market
darknet market ddos spurdomarket market
cannazon market cannazon darknet market
darknet wallstreet market Silkkitie market url
top darknet markets versus darknet market
daeva darknet market tor2door market
black market prescription drugs for sale hydra link
white house darknet market darknet drugs
ironclad darknet market incognito link
darknet market superlist darkc0de
dream market darknet link hydra market
monopoly market url ironclad darknet market
russian darknet market alphabay darknet market
darknet seiten dream market monopoly market darknet
black market prescription drugs for sale darknet links markets
darknet markets reddit 2022 bohemia market
versus project market url grams darknet market search engine
asap darknet market archetyp darknet market
world darknet market versus market darknet
darknet market guide deep web drug markets
drug markets dark web cartel market url
darknet market url cannazon market darknet
darknet markets 2022 reddit daeva market link
магазин гидра сайт гидра
televend market darknet world market link
grams darknet market olympus darknet market
grey market darknet reddit darknet market list 2021
bohemia market darknet daeva market darknet
versus market darknet dark web market links
asap market darknet Spurdomarket market link
cypher market url darknet empire market
zion market darknet darknet market search
core market darknet reddit darknet market list
deep sea darknet market darknet market
world market tor2door market darknet
РіРёРґСЂР° hydra darknet marketplace
cartel market darknet cannazon market darknet
cheap clarinex – clarinex cheap buy triamcinolone 10mg for sale
darknet market reddit best darknet market reddit
liberty darknet market black market prescription drugs for sale
Silkkitie market url grey market darknet
drug markets dark web dark0de market
bohemia market 2022 darknet market
archetyp market url Silkkitie link
гидра ссылка гидра официальный сайт
dark web market list asap market link
best darknet market 2022 darknet market guide reddit
wall street market darknet link nightmare darknet market
tor markets 2021 darknet market forum
darknet market search darknet wallstreet market
wall street market darknet darknet wall street market
televend market url liberty market
cartel marketplace url guide to darknet markets
2021 darknet market tor markets links
wallstreet market url darknet dream market
darknet market search engine how to access the darknet market
versus darknet market samsara darknet market
alphabay market cannahome darknet market
darknet market list incognito darknet market
darknet markets reddit world darknet market
daeva market link tor markets links
cannahome market darknet darknet market lists
darknet market noobs best darknet market reddit
darknet markets reddit reddit darknet market list 2021
tor darknet markets reddit darknet market noobs
alphabay market link onion darknet market
darknet links markets how to get on darknet market
how to buy from the darknet markets darkweb markets
agora darknet market tor2door link
cannazon market url reliable darknet markets
tor2door darknet market black market prescription drugs for sale
olympus darknet market vice city market url
monopoly link guide to darknet markets
the wall street market darknet vice city darknet market
how to get on darknet market torrez link
reddit darknet market noobs darknet drug store
darkc0de liberty market darknet
tor2door market olympus market darknet
monopoly market asap link
drug market darkmarket
versus project market url darknet market bible
bohemia market uk darknet markets
cypher link are there any darknet markets left
versus darknet market wall street market darknet review
dark0de link black market illegal drugs
гидра онион новое зеркало гидры
darknet market arrests darknet market prices
darknet market comparison chart incognito market link
how to get on darknet market alphabay darknet market
Silkkitie market url torrez market url
cannahome market darknet hansa market darknet
darknet drug links wall market darknet
darknet drug links dark market 2022
best darknet market for weed cartel link
black market drugs cannahome market
cartel market versus darknet market
world market darknet darknet seiten dream market
dark market list darknet market url
tor market url drug markets dark web
tor darknet markets darknet market list reddit
black market illegal drugs russian darknet market
hydra onion ссылка гидра сайт ссылка
valhalla darknet market darknet dream market link
liberty darknet market bitcoin dark web
grams darknet market search engine Spurdomarket market darknet
are there any darknet markets left dream market darknet
drug market darknet market comparison
deep web drug links aero market darknet
hydra darknet marketplace hydra darknet
versus project market asap market
tor2door market link top darknet markets
darknet market list darknet drugs
incognito market url incognito market url
torrez market link wall street market darknet reddit
darknet markets reddit alphabay market
best darknet market 2022 monopoly link
deep web markets versus project market link
best australian darknet market new darknet markets
darknet market noobs bible agora darknet market
wall street market darknet review dark web markets
bohemia darknet market cartel market darknet
cypher darknet market onion darknet market
hydra market darknet valhalla darknet market
гидра магазин гидра зеркало
deep web drug url darknet wallstreet market
world darknet market new darknet market reddit
darknet wallstreet market best darknet market for weed
reddit darknet markets 2022 darknet market empire
hydra onion hydra darknet marketplace
black market illegal drugs deep web markets
darknet market url list valhalla darknet market
daeva darknet market silk road darknet market
darknet market arrests uk darknet markets
black market illegal drugs daeva link
hydra darknet market darknet market guide
tor2door market url cartel darknet market
best darknet market 2022 reddit wall market darknet
grams darknet market search tor2door darknet market
cartel marketplace url darknet dream market link
empire market darknet stats dark0de darknet market
grey market darknet tor markets 2022
darkfox market link alphabay link
torrez market url black market prices for drugs
how to get on darknet market liberty market url
darknet market news darknet wall street market
televend market link darknet drugs
liberty market darknet wall street market darknet link
cartel market url wallstreet market url
dark market link asap market link
best darknet market 2022 reddit hansa darknet market
archetyp link white house market darknet
televend market darknet silk road darknet market
white house market url white house market darknet
liberty market darknet safe darknet markets
darknet market list 2021 dark market
archetyp link versus project market url
incognito link darknet market onion links
r darknet market grams darknet market search engine
darkfox link darknet seiten dream market
asap darknet market how to get to darknet market
darknet market prices darknet market script
darknet markets reddit how to get to darknet market
darkweb market darknet wall street market
darkweb markets bohemia market url
cannahome market link how to get on darknet market
гидра шишки гидра официальный сайт
price of black market drugs darkfox market darknet
darknet markets 2021 reddit darknet market url
new darknet market reddit crypto market darknet
black market illegal drugs wall street market darknet reddit
asap link darknet market comparison chart
the wall street market darknet tor2door market url
dark0de darknet market dream market darknet
top darknet markets 2022 silkkitie darknet market
darknet gun market samsara market darknet
black market prices for drugs versus project market
monopoly darknet market monopoly market url
hydra onion РіРёРґСЂР°
darkc0de darknet market list 2022
Spurdomarket link darknet market arrests
darknet market list 2021 torrez link
cypher market darknet nightmare market darknet
darknet market wiki monopoly darknet market
dark market list vice city market darknet
active darknet markets tor market
price of black market drugs darknet market news
dark web market list dark market list
best darknet market australia drug markets dark web
black market illegal drugs tor2door market url
spurdomarket market asap market url
darknet market ddos darknet markets norge
hydra onion shop зайти на гидру
dark web markets bohemia market darknet
incognito darknet market darknet market comparison
darknet markets 2021 silkkitie market
cannahome darknet market darknet market status
РіРёРґСЂР° onion hydra market
darknet markets reddit 2022 reddit darknet market list
how to get on darknet market active darknet markets
deep web markets new darknet markets
dark web market links darknet market forum
tor dark web darknet markets 2022 reddit
silkkitie market darknet market
darkfox market empire market darknet stats
hydra market darknet deep web drug markets
darknet dream market reddit grey market darknet
cannahome market darknet stock market
darknet market url dark0de link
darknet market links dream market darknet url
r darknet market reddit darknet market noobs
wallstreet market url alphabay market url
asap market url tor market links
hydra darknet market darknet market reviews
Spurdomarket link best darknet market 2022 reddit
darknet drug store dark market url
darknet drug store darknet wallstreet market
darknet market news bohemia darknet market
tor marketplace deep web drug url
darknet markets onion address wall street market darknet reddit
darknet links markets drug markets onion
darknet market avengers liberty link
2022 darknet market cannazon darknet market
dark web sites tor2door link
darknet market list 2021 tor2door link
tor2door market url samsara market darknet
tor2door darknet market how to create a darknet market
wall market darknet torrez link
alphabay market darknet Spurdomarket market darknet
reddit darknet market noobs versus project market
darknet markets 2021 bohemia darknet market
tor markets links wall street market darknet review
tor2door darknet market wall street market darknet link
darknet market prices televend market darknet
new darknet market reddit darkmarket 2022
deep web drug links ironclad darknet market
ссылка гидра гидра нарко
black market drugs tor marketplace
popular darknet markets darknet stock market
what is the darknet market darknet markets 2021 reddit
wall street market darknet url darkweb markets
reddit darknet markets 2021 vice city market
darkmarket link incognito link
dark market list monopoly market
best darknet market australia olympus market darknet
spurdomarket darknet market best darknet market 2022 reddit
vice city market darknet tor market links
alphabay market link olympus darknet market
most popular darknet market zion market darknet
darknet wall street market darknet market superlist
asap market url torrez darknet market
white house market link reddit darknet market list
tor2door market darknet darknet market list reddit
tor market links hydra market darknet
black market prescription drugs for sale hydra link
new darknet markets cannahome market
best darknet market for lsd archetyp darknet market
vice city market uk darknet markets
cypher market darknet bohemia darknet market
darknet gun market darknet empire market
wallstreet market link alphabay market
darknet market list 2021 darknet stock market
cypher market darknet tor2door market
drug market versus project market url
versus project darknet market black market drugs
darknet wallstreet market hydra market darknet
hansa market darknet darknet market black
how to buy from the darknet markets darknet drug links
новое зеркало гидры ссылка гидра
silkkitie darknet market biggest darknet market 2021
black market prices for drugs versus market darknet
darknet links markets nightmare darknet market
bitcoin drugs market cannahome market darknet
dream market darknet versus project link
tor market Spurdomarket market link
darknet market avengers white house market darknet
cannahome market darknet best darknet market for lsd
liberty market link versus project market link
core market darknet daeva market link
popular darknet markets popular darknet markets
best darknet market 2021 reddit guide to darknet markets
alphabay link televend market darknet
daeva market url televend market darknet
tor market darknet how to get on darknet market